Tuesday, July 1, 2008

Summary:
Jerry Waxler writes about memoirs and how they are beneficial to both the readers and the writers themselves. Jerry lists different examples of memoirs and how they are influential and purposeful. It’s relating to stories and experiences that other people have written about, but more importantly it’s relating and sharing emotions. Jerry, also talks about personal experiences and research that have led him to believe writing a memoir is a therapeutic event. Jerry explains that Memoirs can be used to help a writer make better sense of there own past, thus learning more about themselves as a human being. There was also an audio portion of the assignment in which a niece was talking and asking questions to her aunt about hurricane Katrina. It focused primarily on the aftermath of the storm which caused the niece and aunt on the audio tape to be relocated to Houston. Some of the questions where about how the situation had made them both stronger individuals and helped them to learn more about themselves and people in general.
Response:
I found these writings to be very interesting, also emotionally stimulating (especially the audio portion about relocating after hurricane Katrina). I agree with jerry and feel that memoirs can be very beneficial and also therapeutic. This seems to be especially true in the case of the writer, more so than the reader, which I found strange because people usually write for the purpose of readers. Memoirs though, seem to be an entirely different case from most forms of writing; they are a service to the writer and therapy for the mind. I agree with Jerry’s overall message although I found his projection of it to be kind of smug. The audio of the Aunt and Niece however was very powerful. It’s very difficult to even imagine what both of them have experienced and although it helped me understand, I could never truly know how it feels to be in there shoes. I do feel through my own interpretation that they learned so much about themselves and others. They’ve seen first hand that even after a massive tragedy people can still grow stronger through finding love and enlightenment.
Questions:
1. Would writing a memoir put stress on an individual to have their future events and moments in life always reach an unachievable standard worth writing about?

2. Could writing a memoir sometimes be a harmful experience to some one who doesn’t want to re-live their past?

3. Is jerry Waxler a well known writer?

2 comments:

Dimples. said...

Hey Alex!
Thank you for commenting my blog. As you already know we have the same views on this reading and audio, but I like how you mentioned that although you understand their situation, you can't truly know what it feels like to be in their shoes. That is very true!

I will attempt to answer your questions. haha..Well, Question number one..Although, I can't speak for everyone, I believe that every moment in life is worth writing about because one second can change your life. I saw a movie once in my German class called "Lola Rennt" (Lola Runs) and it demonstrates how any insignificant thing can change your future/life. It's very intresting and you should take a look at it sometime I rented it at Hollywood video when I moved down to Florida. lol. But anyways, I don't think that one should feel the pressure to live an exciting or traumatic life to write a memoir.

Question number two: "Those who forget the lessons of history are doomed to repeat them"

And by that I mean One should learn from their mistakes and in order to truly get over something and understand what has happened to you, you have to accept it. I know through experience that it is much easier to believe that it never happened, but talking about it or writing it down takes a great amount of stress and burden off one's shoulders!

As for your last question I have no idea! lol. But I hope that I somewhat answered your questions. :)

Well...see you in class!
-Karen Valdovinos

Kathleen "Kat" Robinson-Malone said...

Nice posting and reaction.

I like that the idea of empathy figures into Alex's post. Empathy is very important to develop when you are writing.

Karen---Run, Lola, Run is one of my favorite films. I love how the film is connected by odd symbols like the phone and the various doors--;-)